For people looking for the best Laser treatment in India, Lasik, PRK, and SMILE are the options. These three are the most effective and popular techniques for vision correction. Each method has its considerations and advantages. These surgical processes help individuals achieve brighter or clearer vision without dependence on contact lenses and glasses. This blog about Comparing LASIK vs. SMILE vs. PRK to assist you in making an informed decision about which technique is best for you.

LASIK (Laser-Assisted In Situ Keratomileusis)

Lasik is the go-to option for people looking for a painless and quick procedure for vision correction. In this process, a thin flap is created on the cornea and exposes the underlying tissue, then laser reshapes the cornea to correct the refractive errors. 

Advantages of Lasik Surgery

Lasik surgery boasts a quicker recovery than other surgical procedures by which patients experience enhanced vision within a few days.

During and after the surgery, many patients experience minimal discomfort, but thanks to the use of numbing eye drops and advanced laser technology.

Lasik surgery has a high success rate in achieving enhanced vision, making it a reliable choice for many individuals.

Disadvantages of Lasik Surgery

 A thin flap creation on the cornea during the surgery poses a slight risk of complication, such as epithelial ingrowth or flap dislocation. However, these complications are relatively rare.

Also, people with thin corneas may not be suitable candidates for Lasik surgery because this technique requires a certain amount of corneal tissue thickness for best results.

SMILE (Small Incision Lenticule Extraction) 

SMILE is an advanced laser technique that is FDA-approved and popular for its one-step and minimally invasive procedure. Unlike Lasik, SMILE surgery involves creating a small cut on the cornea using a femtosecond laser. In this procedure, surgeons remove a tiny part of corneal tissue, called a lenticule, reshape the cornea and correct the refractive errors. 

Advantages of SMILE Surgery

SMILE requires a smaller cut compared to Lasik, which reduces the risk of dry eyes after surgery and results in less corneal disruption.

This procedure does not involve creating a flap on the cornea,  showing that the risk of flap-related complications is notably lower. 

It is a minimally invasive technique noiseless, bladeless, and odorless. Suitable for candidates having thin corneal tissue.

Disadvantages of SMILE Surgery

The recovery from SMILE surgery is slightly longer than Lasik surgery. Some individuals experience visual discomfort and blurred vision for days to a week.

SMILE surgery may not be available as widely as Lasik surgery in all regions, limiting accessibility for some patients.

PRK (Photorefractive Keratectomy)

PRK is the first laser vision correction method but an effective procedure that predates SMILE and Lasik. PRK removes the outer layer of the corneal instead of creating a flap before reshaping the underlying tissue with a laser.

Advantages of PRK 

PRK eliminates the risk of flap-related issues, making it a safer option for individuals concerned about potential complications associated with corneal flaps.

Like SMILE, PRK is suitable for individuals with thin corneas, providing an alternative for those who may not be eligible for LASIK.

Some studies suggest that PRK may result in more stable long-term outcomes with a lower risk of regression. 

Disadvantages of PRK

PRK typically involves a more extended recovery period compared to LASIK, with patients experiencing discomfort and blurred vision for several days to a week.

The epithelium removal can cause discomfort during the initial healing phase, which may be a consideration for some individuals.

Which is Best: Comparing LASIK vs. SMILE vs. PRK?

Choosing the right option for vision correction depends on individual factors such as personal preference, lifestyle, and corneal thickness. SMILE, LASIK, and PRK are proven effective methods in providing a clear vision. Ultimately,  the decision depends on the unique characterization of each patient.

Before undergoing any eye procedure, it is essential to have a thorough eye examination. After discussing your options with your surgeon, you can decide which treatment is best for you. Your surgeon may recommend SMILE, LASIK, or PRK based on individual needs and circumstances.

0 0

Written and Verified by:

Dr Madhvendra Singh

MBBS, MS

MEET THE EXPERT